lotr mtg most valuable cards All Lord of the Rings worth money: Holiday price update Top 25 Most Expensive Cards

Dishonorable Mention I feel like we could just make a fart noise, move on, and everyone would kind of get it

Easily one of the most underrated generals in EDH, Sedris, The Traitor King has great synergy with zombies, whether through graveyard unearthing or combo enabling

The showcase Scrolls of Middle-earth cards make up the bulk of each Special Edition Collector Booster

Its hard to consider something truly underrated when it just recently came out, since players may not have discovered it yet or simply havent bought their copy

It might not directly win games, but many, many decks would be worse off if this card never existed in the first place