mtg whenever a player discards a card The 50 Best Discard Cards and Effects in Magic Ranked Megrim · Magic 2010 (M10)

It also makes each opponent lose 2 life and gains you 2 life, so the extra cost is worth it

I know they're thematic but spending five mana to make a 1/1 token is terrible and the situation where you'd actually want to activate it in a game of Commander is so rare that it's simply not worth running it over a different land

Edict most decks make tokens now, so stripping away permanents with single edicts is as bad as its ever been

4 or 5 Comet deals damage equal to the number of loyalty counters on him to a creature or player, then [2]

As for EDH, you can build around this blue commander or just add Kiora to the 99 with your sea monster commanders